(AMS Bumper Sticker)

Web math-frolic.blogspot.com

Friday, December 7, 2012

Why Infinity Will Drive You Bonkers…

You have an infinite number of balls labelled from "1" to infinity.
At one minute to midnight you place balls #1 through #10 in a box and simultaneously the #1 ball is removed.

At 1/2 minute to midnight you place the #11 through #20 balls in the same box and simultaneously remove the #2 ball.

At 1/3 minute to midnight you place the #21 through #30 balls into the box, removing the #3 ball.

At 1/4 minute to midnight…....... removing the #4 ball.

...and you continue on with the same pattern. . . . .

How many balls are in the box at midnight???  At first glance it would seem there could be an infinite number, i.e. 9+9+9+9+…
However, for ANY ball "#n" that you might assume remains in the box, it can be deduced that THAT ball was REMOVED from the box at the 1/n-of-a-minute time point... thus all balls get removed; the box is empty!

I adapted this from a version at another site:


This is known as the Ross-Littlewood Paradox and you can read more about it here:

It is similar to a more involved Raymond Smullyan puzzle I've posted about previously (...if your mind isn't already blown):


No comments: