Friday, December 7, 2012

Why Infinity Will Drive You Bonkers…

You have an infinite number of balls labelled from "1" to infinity.
At one minute to midnight you place balls #1 through #10 in a box and simultaneously the #1 ball is removed.

At 1/2 minute to midnight you place the #11 through #20 balls in the same box and simultaneously remove the #2 ball.

At 1/3 minute to midnight you place the #21 through #30 balls into the box, removing the #3 ball.

At 1/4 minute to midnight…....... removing the #4 ball.

...and you continue on with the same pattern. . . . .

How many balls are in the box at midnight???  At first glance it would seem there could be an infinite number, i.e. 9+9+9+9+…
However, for ANY ball "#n" that you might assume remains in the box, it can be deduced that THAT ball was REMOVED from the box at the 1/n-of-a-minute time point... thus all balls get removed; the box is empty!

I adapted this from a version at another site:  

This is known as the Ross-Littlewood Paradox and you can read more about it here:

It is similar to a more involved Raymond Smullyan puzzle I've posted about previously (...if your mind isn't already blown):

No comments: