Wednesday, November 28, 2018

What A Life!


Many readers here will have enjoyed various videos done by Stanford mathematician Tadashi Tokieda for the Numberphile site or elsewhere, but probably, like me, didn’t know much about his background. Erica Klarreich has now given us a wonderful profile of the man behind the mellifluous voice and sparkling “toy” videos (and his "unusual path into mathematics"). I encourage everyone to read one of the most fascinating brief portraits I’ve ever encountered:


Here’s a summary of some of the high points, but do read the entire interview to fill in all the details:

1)  He doesn’t find puzzles, games, and the like particularly interesting, because they are man-made with artificial man-made rules and set-ups. The “toys” he finds intriguing are simply a part of nature or life that become interesting when closely examined.

2)  When young he thought he would become a painter/artist — something he was very good at. And even now acknowledges that “In some sense, drawing and pictures are still what I care about most.”

3)  Later, living in Japan, he had “a real epiphany” about language, eventually leading to a decision to learn various languages and become a philologist.

4)  By chance, needing something to read on a train trip, he picked up a biography of Russian physicist Lev Landau. It opened his eyes to science, math, and specifically calculus, which he then decided he must learn.

5)  Landau suggested learning math, not with classes or lectures, but by finding “a book with the largest number of solved exercises and go through them all.” The book Tokieda found was in Russian which he didn’t know, but as a philologist was willing to learn.

6)  Eventually (within months actually) he says he found he “was fairly good at this kind of silly manipulative exercise,” and then proceeded to enroll at Oxford in a two-year undergraduate program in mathematics. He didn’t know English, by the way, but what the heck, just another language to quickly learn!

7)  Soon he realized mathematics was what he wanted to do for a living, and was off to Princeton for a Ph.D. program.
…And, as they say, the rest is history. ;)
(He's currently a professor of mathematics at Stanford.)

I’ll stop here, but the last several paragraphs of the Quanta piece are also great reading (Tokieda’s take on math and his own videos... including making children happy), so be sure to read the whole piece.

…If I had read of Tokieda’s life, as Klarreich reports it here, in a novel, I would’ve thought, ‘what a pile of non-believable fiction this is… there could never be such a character in real life.’ …And yet apparently there is!

One last note: Quanta is recently out with two compendiums of their many superb articles on math, and on the sciences, particularly physics... this Klarreich profile is one more of many they've now done on individual scientists/mathematicians. I suspect that somewhere in the future there may be a collection of these profiles available as well.
[Addendum: I've now noticed that several of these profiles are already included in the math volume, The Prime Number Conspiracy.]





Sunday, November 25, 2018

A Li'l Physics, and more, With Eric Weinstein


Polymath (and member of the so-called “Intellectual Dark Web”) Eric Weinstein is a bit of an odd-duck — I often agree with his take on various matters and usually find him interesting (whether in agreement or not), but also occasionally find him infuriating. Anyway, he recently did a long (almost 4 hr.!) stint with Joe Rogan where he attempts at one point (beginning ~41:20 mark) to give Joe and listening audience a primer on fundamental physics that lasts about an hour:


A couple other shorter segments I enjoyed:

A bit of discussion of the ‘craft’ of comedy versus that of physics (starting ~1:36:10):


Followed by a short lesson from Eric on harmonica music (starting ~1:40:20):


There are many other interesting bits in the whole podcast (which touches on a LOT of diverse topics), though I thought the first half more interesting overall than the 2nd half.

Eric, an economist by trade and mathematical physicist by academic degree (who, in his spare time, is working on his own 'theory of everything'), has appeared in many other podcasts/videos as well.


[...by the way, he should NOT be confused with "Eric Weisstein" who runs "Wolfram MathWorld" -- 2 completely different people.]



Friday, November 23, 2018

Chi-i-i-i-i-i-ll Friday *





[*  "Chill Friday" is Math-Frolic's meditative musical diversion, heading into each weekend]




Monday, November 19, 2018

Book Mentions....


First off, John Golden recently tweeted out this video on math and analogies from Kalid  Azad over at “Better Explained,” that I thought worth passing along (once again it touches on the interplay of math and language as I was musing about in my recent post, and as Jim Propp also broaches in his latest offering:


————————————
(via: http://www.clipartsuggest.com )
Moving on, it’s been another great year in mathy popular books, with a mini-flurry of volumes showing up in the final three months of the year.  Of the books I’ve already read, I recently tweeted out my 5 faves, one of which I’ll soon cite as my 2018 ’book-of-the-year,’ but for now will hold ya all in suspense ;)

When Einstein Met Gödel -- Jim Holt
Math With Bad Drawings -- Ben Orlin
Exact Thinking In Demented Times -- Karl Sigmund
Closing the Gap -- Vicky Neale
Hello World -- Hannah Fry

Meanwhile, Thomas Lin (as editor) is newly-out with “The Prime Number Conspiracy,” a collection of pieces from that outstanding stable of writers at Quanta Magazine.  I haven’t seen it yet, but no doubt it would easily break into my select group above if I had.

And since citing the above, Mircea Pitici’s latest “Best Writing On Mathematics” for 2018 has appeared; delighted to see it materialize in my mailbox... knowing that Mircea has had some topsy-turvy changes in his life this year, I wasn’t sure he’d have the time/inclination to do another edition — but he has and it contains his typical variety of diverse selections (something for everyone). I received the volume just a couple of days after my Nov. 11 posting and so was heartened to see several picks in it dealing with creativity, paradox/puzzles, and beauty in math, as well as Wigner’s “unreasonable effectiveness” notion (all things I’d been thinking about lately).

From Brian Kernighan (and Princeton University Press) comes Millions, Billions, Zillions: Defending Yourself in a World of Too Many Numbers a small, stocking-stuffer-sized book aimed at bestowing basic numeracy to readers.

And am currently reading/enjoying “The Model Thinker” by Scott Page (from Basic Books) — a book for which I'd seen no prior buzz or publicity before its arrival. It’s another in the string of volumes covering big data, modeling, algorithms, probabilities and the like, for a mass audience, but with more textbook-like intros to an array of data/statistical subjects than most previous volumes have offered. Lots of interesting topics. If you’ve been looking for a ‘meatier,’ more mathematical, take in this genre this may be it.

Enough said for now… in another week or two I’ll have my final book wrap-up of the year (including a few additional book mentions) for anyone with math bibliophile friends-or-family on their Holiday list… or, for themselves!



Friday, November 16, 2018

Chi-i-i-i-i-i-ll Friday *






[ *  "Chill Friday" is Math-Frolic's meditative musical diversion, heading into each weekend]


Sunday, November 11, 2018

Sunday Night Ramble…


"If my mental processes are determined wholly by the motion of atoms in my brain, I have no reason to believe that my beliefs are true... and hence I have no reason for supposing my brain to be composed of atoms."--- J.B.S. Haldane, "Possible Worlds" (1927)
“The miracle of the appropriateness of the language of mathematics for the formulation of the laws of physics is a wonderful gift which we neither understand nor deserve. We should be grateful for it and hope that it will remain valid in future research and that it will extend, for better or for worse, to our pleasure, even though perhaps also to our bafflement, to wide branches of learning.”— Eugene V. Wigner
(longish ramble ahead....)
Last Friday was one of those oddly serendipitous days in some ways — and that’s despite the fact that I was stewing over missing Ben Orlin’s night-before presentation at our local University. ARRRRRRRGH!! — had planned for weeks to attend, but for a whole series of reasons didn’t make it. Luckily, someone had posted his hour-talk from a previous stop (which I assume was the same as here), so I went online later and viewed that.

A couple days prior, a mathematician/blogger had sent along something to read for any comments, and parts of it reminded me of a favorite quote I’ve used here previously from provocateur David Berlinski (for those who’ve seen me employ it multiple previous times I beg forgiveness, and indeed apologies for all the long quotes coming below):
"Like any other mathematician, Euclid took a good deal for granted that he never noticed.  In order to say anything at all, we must suppose the world stable enough so that some things stay the same, even as other things change. This idea of general stability is self-referential. In order to express what it says, one must assume what it means. Euclid expressed himself in Greek; I am writing in English. Neither Euclid's Greek nor my English says of itself that it is Greek or English. It is hardly helpful to be told that a book is written in English if one must also be told that written in English is written in English. Whatever the language, its identification is a part of the background. This particular background must necessarily remain in the back, any effort to move it forward leading to an infinite regress, assurances requiring assurances in turn. These examples suggest what is at work in any attempt to describe once and for all the beliefs 'on which all men base their proofs.' It suggests something about the ever-receding landscape of demonstration and so ratifies the fact that even the most impeccable of proofs is an artifact."-- D. Berlinski (from "The King of Infinite Space")
The interplay of language, meaning, abstraction, perception… and, mathematics/science is an ongoing interest of mine. Another quote I’ve used elsewhere is from venerable Bertrand Russell toward the end of a frustrating career (1957) trying to formalize all of mathematics:
"I have come to believe, though very reluctantly, that it [mathematics] consists of tautologies. I fear that, to a mind of sufficient intellectual power, the whole of mathematics would appear trivial, as trivial as the statement that a four-legged animal is an animal."  

Again, I think this reflects on the complex interplay of language and human thought — hmmm, all of mathematics as tautologies?… maybe all of meaning is tautological, just substituting one set of human scratchings or sounds for another… is all of knowledge just one gigantic Thesaurus? ;)) No, I don’t believe that, but a lot of “knowledge” does seem illusory or mirage-like and certainly changing. Often meanings, metaphors, analogies and the like simply refer back on themselves within an enclosed bubble.

Later on Friday afternoon I stumbled across this new essay at the Scientific American site, “Proofs and Guarantees” (actually reprinted from “The Mathematical Intelligencer”), which seemed to hit some of the same notes, questioning assumptions. It ends accepting the “fallibility of the initial axioms or other first principles” of math, and thus acknowledging an evolutionary nature to mathematics, as something that is not necessarily fixed over time (just as science is not static and self-corrects over time):

In arguments between math Platonists and non-Platonists it’s often contended that even (philosophical) non-Platonists ARE Platonists-at-heart when it comes to their livelihood… i.e., a pure mathematician must presume math exists out there to be discovered, in order to carry on their daily work. That may overstate the case, but on-the-other-hand one of my favorite volumes is by non-Platonist, retired mathematician William Byers, “How Mathematicians Think.” The subheading to the book title is: “Using Ambiguity, Contradiction, and Paradox to Create Mathematics” and that succinctly sums up what he argues in the volume, that mathematics is “created” out of the very things that most people presume run counter to it.
Interestingly, a second major influence in Byers’ life (besides mathematics) is Zen Buddhism, known for its mystical focus on contradictions. Here is one passage where he touches upon it:
“The second strand in my life was and is a strenuous practice of Zen Buddhism. Zen helped me confront aspects of my life that went beyond the logical and the mathematical. Zen has the reputation for being antilogical, but that is not my experience. My experience is that Zen is not confined to logic; it does not see logic as having the final word. Zen demonstrates that there is a way to work with situations of conflict, situations that are problematic from a normal, rational point of view. The rational, for Zen, is just another point of view. Paradox, in Zen, is used constructively as a way to direct the mind to subverbal levels out of which acts of creativity arise.”
Later in the volume he writes:
“…every human being lives in a bubble. This bubble contains all their perceptions and cognitions. What exists outside the bubble is not knowable. Radical constructivists 'do not make claims about what exists in itself, that is, without an observer or experiencer.' This is a point that I also made earlier when I claimed that there exists no mathematical knowledge that is completely objective. Mathematical knowledge and truth must be considered as a package with both objective and subjective aspects. The belief in ‘objective mathematical knowledge,’ that is, knowledge that is independent of the beings who know it, is itself a belief and therefore nonobjective. There is no knowledge that is independent of knowing. There is no absolute, objective truth.”
And finally, here’s Byers, at length, in another book, “The Blind Spot,” hitting the same theme:
"It is certainly conceivable that the clarity we perceive in the world is something we bring to the world, not something that is there independent of us. The clarity of the natural world is a metaphysical belief that we unconsciously impose on the situation. We consider it to be obvious that the natural world is something exterior of us and independent of our thoughts and sense impressions; we believe in a mind-independent reality. Paradoxically, we do not recognize that the belief in a mind-independent reality is itself mind-dependent. Logically, we cannot work our way free of the bubble we live in, which consists of all of our sense impression and thoughts. The pristine world of clarity, the natural world independent of the observer, is merely a hypothesis that cannot, in principle, ever be verified. To say that the natural world is ambiguous is to highlight this assumption. It is to emphasize that the feeling that there is a natural world 'out there' that is the same for all people at all times, is an assumption that is not self-evident. This is not to embrace a kind of solipsism and to deny the reality of the world. It is to emphasize that the natural world is intimately intertwined with the world of the mind. In consequence, the natural world is a flow just like the inner world. By stabilizing the inner world through language, logic, mathematics, and science, we simultaneously stabilize the outer world. The result of all this is the recognition that the clarity we assume to be a basic feature of the natural world merely masks a deeper ambiguity. One of the functions of mathematics and science is precisely to deny this ambiguity. This is really the motivation behind the science of certainty." 
Anyway, finally coming back around to Dr. Orlin’s talk, which is all about the relationship between mathematics and science, Ben concludes that they share a symbiotic relationship — two quite DIFFERENT activities feeding off one another (as opposed to the more common conception of math being foundational to science). I couldn’t help but think that perhaps that viewpoint might be broadened out to describe the relationship/interplay between language, thought, and math… entities that are separate but very much feed off one another (though many mathematical aspects of language may not even yet be understood/appreciated).
Give Ben's entertaining, thoughtful talk a watch if you’ve not seen it:


David Chalmers famously talks about consciousness as the “hard problem” of philosophy and psychology, left untouched by resolving the other “easy” or soft problems. How do subjectively-felt  experiences arise out of the conglomeration of matter that is our physical brain? Or, in Thomas Nagel’s famous take, what does it feel like to be a bat?
In recent years there has been a lot discussion and competing theories over “consciousness.” Certainly some of Doug Hofstadter’s past writings touch on these matters, as does Joselle sometimes over at her Mathrising blog… and many many more [including, if you haven't seen it, John Horgan's latest 'free' volume on consciousness, where he speaks to several major thinkers on the topic, HERE].
But then another favorite quote of mine (from Emerson Pugh) is, “If the human brain were so simple that we could understand it, we would be so simple that we couldn’t,” implying that  we will never be able to turn the brain on itself to reveal its own deepest secrets. That’s a sort of “Mysterian” viewpoint (and I’m in the mysterian camp with Colin McGinn, Martin Gardner, Roger Penrose, and others, but plenty of folks oppose it, believing the brain can be fully understood, even duplicated).
Anyway, similarly, I think mathematics has a ‘hard’ problem (philosophically-speaking). It is the one made famous by physicist Eugene Wigner (quoted above). How does one account for the exquisite fit of abstract mathematics with the physical world as we interpret it? How indeed! Max Tegmark’s tempting answer is that fundamentally, mathematics is all there is… mathematics IS the core foundational structure/component of the Universe, or of reality; an intriguing notion, but difficult to flesh out, and not one I see a lot of others gravitating toward. Even if you're a full-out Platonist (like Gödel) and believe mathematics exists in the world, independent of humans, the question remains where did it come from and how are we humans able to access it so successfully? Or has some alien civilization, a million years more advanced than us, recognized mathematics as a truly tautological illusion, and moved on to something else more fundamental by now?
Finally, there's been a lot of emphasis in recent years on "beauty" in mathematics, but now even that view is being drawn into question, with a lot of buzz in particular around Sabine Hossenfelder's recent volume, "Lost In Math" (on modern physics), where she argues the myopic focus on beauty simply leads us astray. Is nothing sacred anymore!... first taking away certainty and truth, and now even our wistful love of beauty. ;)
More and more, I find pieces I'm reading connect somehow back to these interests in language, cognition, consciousness, recursion... maybe some day our grandchildren's grandchildren... or, Ben Orlin... will actually make sense of it all! 

Well, I've let the atoms in my brain (assuming they exist) bounce around a bit too much tonight... time to put them to bed, and perhaps go flying -- something I do quite splendidly in my dreams, but, frustratingly, can't seem to do upon awakening (...though, as Chuang Tzu might ponder, perhaps my flying is real and it's this blog-writing that is just a dream....)
----------------------------------

==> Enough of my stream-of-consciousness, IF you want to hear from a real mathematician, I listened to Numberphile's maiden podcast earlier today with Grant Sanderson (of 3Blue1Brown), and it's quite good:
https://www.numberphile.com/podcast/3blue1brown



Friday, November 9, 2018

Chi-i-i-i-i-i-ll Friday *





[ *  "Chill Friday" is Math-Frolic's meditative musical diversion, heading into each weekend]


Sunday, November 4, 2018

More Collaboration and Less Collusion!


via Redbooth.com

January marks the 10-year anniversary of the collaborative “Polymath Project” begun by Fields Medalist Tim Gowers. Let’s celebrate early!
Here is the main page for the Project:
…and here is the Tim Gowers posting that originally proposed such a crowdsourcing effort be attempted:

I find it interesting how little widespread digital collaboration has made a dent in other sciences, but been productive in mathematics — one suspects there’s some sort of whole sociological dissertation that could be written here! (although perhaps the pen-and-paper, and computer-assisted nature of mathematics makes it more suited to such endeavors than other more applied sciences)
Anyway, Vicky Neale in her fabulous volume “Closing the Gap,” writes a lot about Polymath’s contributions to the ongoing work on the Twin Primes conjecture. She includes many wonderful quotes from Gowers along the way. Here he is when first proposing a digital collaboration on significant unsolved math problems:
“The ideal solution would be a solution of the problem with no single individual having to think all that hard. The hard thought would be done by a sort of super-mathematician whose brain is distributed amongst bits of the brais of lots of interlinked people. So try to resist the temptation to go away and think about something and come back with carefully polished thoughts: just give quick reactions to what you read and hope that the conversation will develop in good directions.”
Neale then writes, “Gowers was very keen to encourage participants to share their immediate thoughts, rather than working on ideas independently in private, with an emphasis on expressing their immediate thoughts as clearly as possible so that others could build on them.” 
And then she quotes Gowers again:
“When you do research, you are more likely to succeed if you try out lots of stupid ideas. Similarly stupid comments are welcome here. (In the sense to which I am using ’stupid,’ it means something completely different from ‘unintelligent’. It just means not fully thought through.)”
Later on he writes, “…even ‘frivolous’ observations can (and should) be posted on this thread, if there is even a small chance that some other participant may be able to find it helpful for solving the problem.
“Similarly, ‘failed’ attempts at a solution are also worth posting: another participant may be able to salvage the argument, or else the failure can be used as a data point to eliminate some approaches to the problem, and to isolate more promising ones.”

Gowers also foresaw the problem of assigning 'credit’ for such widespread collaborations, and so addressed that ahead of time as well:
“Suppose the experiment actually results in something publishable. Even if only a very small number of people contribute the lion’s share of the ideas, the paper will still be submitted under a collective pseudonym with a link to the entire online discussion.”
Later in the book Neale references how Terry Tao deferred to recent-grad James Maynard to insure he would get the most credit for advances to the Twin Prime conjecture that both had made independently — Tao, absolutely established in his field with no need for acclaim, knowing that credit to Maynard might boost his career greatly — I don’t know that this type of gesture/collegiality would occur very often in any field outside of mathematics!
At this point the Polymath Project has met much success (with fits and starts) and is working on its 16th project. Congratulations to all participants involved, and to Tim Gowers' foresight. As the post-title above suggests, here's to more collaboration in life, and less collusion! ;)

For entertainment purposes only, I’ll end with a completely different take on collaboration in math, in the form of a wonderful short piece of film fiction (on the Goldbach conjecture) that I haven’t re-posted for awhile — for any who have never seen it, “The Calculus of Love”:




Friday, November 2, 2018

Chi-i-i-i-i-i-ll Friday *





[ *  "Chill Friday" is Math-Frolic's meditative musical diversion, heading into each weekend]



Monday, October 29, 2018

Thesis Psalm


Some time ago while re-reading an old John Barrow volume, “Pi In the Sky” I ran across this delightful bit of parody at the end of a section essentially on the foundational math conflict between formalism and intuitionism:

The Lord is my thesis adviser; I shall not err.
He arranges for me to be published in the
respectable journals; he teaches me how
to use the reductio argument.
He enshores my validity; he leads me by
the classical logic, for the truth's sake.
Yea, though I walk through the valley of
the existence proofs, I will fear no contradiction;
for he edits my work.
The Axiom of Choice and Zorn's Lemma, they comfort me.

He invites a colloquium on classical analysis,
for my participation, in the absence of the constructivists;
He frequently and approvingly abstracts me
in Mathematical Reviews;
my reputation flourishes internationally.
Surely, honors and grants shall follow me
all the days of my career,
and I shall rise in the ranks of the
Department,
to Emeritus.

Amen.

[the verse was not attributed to anyone, so I’m not clear if Barrow penned it himself — a quick internet search didn’t help, but if someone knows the author is other than Barrow please let us know]



Friday, October 26, 2018

Chi-i-i-i-i-i-ll Friday *






[ *  "Chill Friday" is Math-Frolic's meditative musical diversion, heading into each weekend]


Monday, October 22, 2018

Ponytail Math


(via WikimediaCommons & Quinn Dombrowski)
The most recent issue of Chalkdust Magazine (downloadable as a pdf) includes an article on the mathematics of ponytails (because, of course, math IS everywhere ;)

I’ve always liked ponytails (on females), and imagine most guys do; never cared much for pigtails, braids, bouffants, beehives, or a bunch of other contortions women put their hair through, but simple ponytails are coool! And according to the above piece, ponytails have “Rapunzel numbers” that help achieve a wide, bushy effect under the influence of gravity (and yes, there's a specific equation for it)… so read up! 
This got me to wondering if anyone else had looked at ponytails from a mathematical angle. And googling a bit, wouldn’t you know, Keith Devlin addressed the topic for NPR back in 2012:

Wherein he writes in part:
“Unilever makes hair care products. And we're talking about a $40 billion global market in shampoos and conditioners. So they got some mathematicians to come up with a mathematical formula to understand how to make more attractive ponytails so that the ponytail curves around in a beautiful, sexy, attractive arc, rather than just hanging limply. That's a $40 billion question.”
Keith never specifically mentions the “Rapunzel” factor but does conclude that density, elasticity, and curliness, are the 3 hair fiber components to an attractive ponytail.
The abstract for the actual British study Dr. Devlin was reporting on is here:
Worth noting too that this study won the Ig Nobel Prize for physics in 2012!: ;)
https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/scicurious-brain/ignobel-prize-winner-in-physics-the-amazing-ponytail/  

Finally, an updated 2017 version of the topic (from one of the original authors, and including plenty of real math) is here:
http://brewminate.com/leonardo-rapunzel-and-the-mathematics-of-hair/
It turns out that even the Wikipedia page for "ponytail" includes a section on the ponytail math/equation:

Now, if someone would just kindly point me to some mathematical studies of male pattern baldness (sometimes known as the non-hairy ball theorem)…. 
[also, lots more to enjoy in the current issue of Chalkdust, linked to above].


Friday, October 19, 2018

Chi-i-i-i-i-i-ll Friday *






[*  "Chill Friday" is Math-Frolic's meditative musical diversion, heading into each weekend]



Wednesday, October 17, 2018

Seeing Ain't Believing...

             "Somethin's happenin' here; what it is ain't exactly clear..."
                                                        -- Buffalo Springfield

At some point last week John Baez sent out this tweet and optical illusion and I found it quite remarkable:

There are a great many such “motion” illusions. They are fascinating and a constant reminder of how easily manipulated human perception is.
Here’s another favorite of mine:

Some additional ones can be seen here (and there are many more):

Anyway, a day or two after John's post Mike Lawler (and others) tweeted out this “motion” illusion, remarking how amazing it was; some even calling it one of the strongest illusions they had ever seen! 


Yet I, and some other folks got little from this example.  The prior examples are those of motion that is mis-perceived, while this is one where motion that doesn’t even occur is perceived to take place. There are many examples of this genre of illusion, and I’ve probably seen at least 20+ I find more effective than this one — you can google “motion optical illusions” to find many; embiggen them for better effect (...FWIW, I also always had problems seeing the old “magic eye” pictures). For that matter, there are a multitude of static (motionless) optical illusions I find far more impressive than the above heralded illusion.
So I’m very curious what is going on with those of us who see little motion with this particular one? What divides the individuals who do and don’t “fall” for this illusion? Are there divisions along gender or age, left-handed vs. right-handed, Chinese-speaking vs. English, or other significant categories? Some explanations lean toward differences in depth perception... but then do those differences themselves fall along any category lines, or are they just randomly dispersed in the population?
We know from court cases, and psychology experiments for that matter, how weak eyewitness testimony can be even though people have great confidence in their visual conclusions. I wonder too, more generally, what differences may exist between people who seem to handle high-level abstraction (as in math) fairly easily, and those who have great difficulty dealing with concepts they can't "picture" in their head -- is there a difference in how these groups "see" certain optical illusions? So many questions???
I suspect the differences in responses to various illusions has been well-studied before, perhaps even some PhD. theses; it certainly seems fodder for analysis.

Meanwhile, not at all an illusion, but simply a mesmerizing visual delight, I'll close out with this deeeep zoom into the Mandelbrot Set... enjoy!:





Sunday, October 14, 2018

Good Math + Bad Drawings = Great Book!


   At some point awhile back I wrote that Ben Orlin’s mind was either a marvel or a mutation… and I wasn’t sure which. Having finished his marvelous new book I’ll now opt for the former (though a final check with his wife and 23-and-Me might still be in order).
Won’t do a full review of “Math With Bad Drawings” but just make some comments/blurbs about the volume. The first of which is simply, BUY this book, if you enjoy math… or, want to enjoy math. It is suitable for a wide swathe of readers, from young people to college professors — all will gain insights from it, just different ones depending on your age and knowledge. Younger folks can be introduced to a lot of real life math, while adults/teachers/profs can learn new ways/examples with which to approach or think about topics. Its broad possible appeal reminds me a bit of Steve Strogatz's "The Joy of X," another sort of everyman book.
Despite only 5 sections (comprising 24 chapters) the volume touches on an impressive array of topics… with consistent wit, insight, humor, clarity. If you’re not already a Ben Orlin fan you’ll be one by the time you finish these 350 grin-inducing pages. You can figure on 4 chuckles per page (OK, so maybe 7 chuckles on some pages and 1 on others). Ben is simply one of the cleverest writers of math content going… you know this already if you’ve followed his blog for some time.
Amazingly, the book is all NEW material. When he originally announced the volume I assumed it would be a compendium of the best stuff from his blog — something surely to look forward to. Then he said it was all fresh material not from the blog, and I was amazed, even skeptical… and sad to think that so much great prior content would not be included; BUUUUT, it does not disappoint!  I especially like the middle parts on probability and statistics, which represent a large percentage of the book, and which are frequent/vital topics these days, that Ben still manages new ways to present.
Indeed Dr. Orlin seems incapable of writing bad or boring content; you get a feeling of precision, quality, tight control throughout this volume, despite the ever-present quirkiness… and bad (or, deceptively good) drawings. And the publisher, Black Dog & Leventhal, has simply done a fabulous job of presentation here — seriously, one of the best publishing feats in popular math I’ve ever seen, with, shall I say, oddball material. When I interviewed Ben back HERE, he mentioned the publisher did a great job, noting:
“…they make gorgeous, colorful books so luscious you want to eat them. Having seen the final product I am 300% sure it was the right call.”
I thought he might be exaggerating… but, no, he wasn’t. The book is luscious (initially I had an urge to slather it with whipped cream ;).
My only beef at all with the volume is that there is no index provided. Dr. Orlin covers a rollicking range of topics, but if you want to look one up to see if it’s included and go directly to it, you’re out of luck (though the table of contents at front gives at least some guidance).
I’d be hardpressed to think of any math volume as original and creative as this one. And the best news may be that Ben is working on a followup volume, introducing calculus… with, of course, deliciously bad drawings. Pass me the derivatives and gravy!



Friday, October 12, 2018

Chi-i-i-i-i-i-ll Friday *






[*  "Chill Friday" is Math-Frolic's meditative musical diversion, heading into each weekend]

[...on Sunday evening, or Monday morning at latest, I'll say a little more about Ben Orlin's new book, "Math With Bad Drawings"]


Wednesday, October 10, 2018

Can I Hear You Now?...



No math today, just a personal anecdote perhaps having relevance to hearing-impaired others. Over the years I’ve had casual conversations with a number of scientists, mathematicians, and personal acquaintances, about hearing loss (afflicting close to 50 million folks as they get older), and what follows is just a personal experience from this sample-size of one:
[hearing loss comes in a multitude of forms, so my experience may not apply to others]

Close to 20 years ago I awoke one morning and quickly realized much of my hearing in one ear was gone! Bingo. (other ear unaffected) After some retrospection I realized my hearing had probably been gradually declining over the prior year and simply passed some threshold that made it readily apparent to me that morning. At any rate, the doctor could figure out no cause for the loss and was quite baffled, even though I logically deduced what I believe with near certainty was the cause (but won't take time to explain here) — every hearing doctor/otolaryngologist I’ve talked to says my explanation isn't valid, which frankly, only makes me distrustful of their understanding of hearing complexities! 

The doctor further said that the kind of hearing loss I had would get gradually worse over time, and that hearing aids would do little good; eventually a cochlear implant would be needed. Also, I should be checked every year to track the progression of the loss. 

Stubborn oaf that I am (when it comes to many medical matters) I’ve never been re-checked in the almost 20 years since, but have watched my hearing very slowly decline further. Hearing aids generally aren’t covered by insurance and are expensive, on the order of $2000 - $3000 or more including all the office visits — there are additional maintenance costs along the way, and they may only be good for 5 years or less, before you need to upgrade. In short, there are a few dozen causes (even more in the Trump era) I’d prefer to see that money go to than to my right ear (and getting by with one good ear is do-able, if limiting).

Over the years I’ve tried a few cheap Personal Sound Amplifier Products (PSAPs) sold over-the-counter, which are quick to emphasize they are NOT “hearing aids” but simply sound amplifiers.  They do what they say they’ll do — amplify sound, all sound (although you can purchase more expensive models that have some filtering and directional capabilities). I’ve been surprised though by how helpful they are — for listening to a TV, lecture, movie, or other point-source of sound; they are less helpful in noisy rooms/gatherings, and the like. So even the cheapest ones, ~$20, when compared to thousands of dollars for hearing aids or tens of thousands of dollars for a cochlear implant, actually have some value. They can however be awkward, inconvenient, and eat through expensive batteries, and be less usable during athletics or other physical activities, so I was never terribly thrilled with them. The quality and variety of these products seems to be significantly improving however, with time and expanding customer-base. 

Recently I had occasion to get one (again for $20) that is small, discreet, usable during many sports, and best-of-all, re-chargeable (no need to buy batteries every month). I’ve been pleasantly surprised at just how well it works — each year I’ve gotten closer to looking into cochlear implants, but at least for the moment, feel I can once again put that off for quite awhile.
I won’t name the cheapie model I got that beat my expectations, but will say there are LOTS of these small behind-the-ear PSAPs available now, ranging up to several hundred dollars (and given how well this $20 model works for me, I’d definitely consider upgrading to a more expensive one later). If you Google “hearing amplifiers” you’ll learn of a slew of them with varying features/styles (and various pros and cons).

One reason I put off for many years buying this particular device is because it not only looked and was cheap (and made in China), but I saw several bad reviews of it on the Web (also saw good reviews, but thought the number of bad reviews was telling). In retrospect, my cynical-self now wonders if any (many?) of those bad reviews are ‘planted’ by the hearing-aid industry who probaby don’t want folks looking at $20-$100 devices that might do some good, when they’re trying to sell you $2000+ devices? (and many of my friends with real hearing aids have significant issues with them, even after spending that amount of money). Of course you have to be somewhat leery of all reviews on the internet anyway! As the population continues to age, hearing aids are definitely a boom product with huge profits to be made, and a lot of competitors vying for a slice of those profits.

If you’ve been putting off dealing with hearing loss (as most do) for the usual sorts of reasons, these more-reasonably priced devices may be worth exploring (while also acknowledging that a do-it-yourself approach is not advisable in many cases). I've had good luck my entire adult life treating myself for typical health ailments, while also sensing when professional medical intervention may be called for. Your mileage may vary. ;) And if one day self-care or treatment costs me dearly, well, que sera sera... (I'm stoic about such matters).
Anyway, as someone who more-often-than-not is disappointed in products I purchase, this has been an instance of low expectations being happily well-exceeded... just a personal anecdote, for any who may get some encouragement from it.

----------------------------------
ADDENDUM:  just a bit of update (1/5/19) for whatever it's worth…
after 4 months of frequent use the $20 PSAP became a little more glitchy… requiring a bit of fidgeting and more frequent battery re-charges — still, I was quite pleased with it, especially given that I wore it during sports and heavy sweating at the end of summer, despite cautions that it shouldn’t (because of electronics) be exposed to dampness. I still use it part of every day.  But I was curious what a more expensive model might do, so after much research ordered another model of PSAP for ~$75. It’s slightly sturdier, but also slightly bulkier (with a less snug, comfortable fit, especially for all-day wear); it gives slightly improved hearing features/sound filtering, but also after a few weeks required more frequent re-charging and fidgeting, and combined with the lower comfort-level (for me) I can’t view it as 3-4 times “better” than my prior choice (though it was ~4 times costlier). I won’t likely need another PSAP anytime soon, but when I do I’ll be torn between simply going back for another $20 model or trying out something in the $120 - $150 range. As time goes on I can only imagine these devices will continue to improve, become even more readily-available, and lower in price.  I also suspect the selection of re-chargeable models will continue to grow -- currently models running on batteries remain the bulk of choices.
[One further note I'll make is that both devices I currently have were made in China, and I do now wonder if ones produced in Germany or Japan might have better overall quality control and be worth looking at more closely.  Also, after much wear, the re-chargeable products I've chosen, require more frequent charging than they did initially -- it may be worth considering battery operated versions, of which there are MANY, even though the cost of batteries would be recurring.]



Sunday, October 7, 2018

Insure THIS!


I found Chapter 14 (on “Weird Insurance”) of Ben Orlin’s delightful volume “Math With Bad Drawings” to be one of the most fun (of so many). It falls within an overall section on probability, and describes several non-standard insurances I’d never given much thought to. One of them he calls, “Oh No, My Employees All Won the Lottery” Insurance. We’ve all read stories in recent years of employees at a workplace banding together to purchase many tickets in some multi-million dollar lottery and then if one person wins, splitting the proceeds… and, then turning in their job resignations en masse.  As Ben puts it, it’s “like some kind of natural disaster” for the manager/proprietor of such a business. Oy.

Ben goes on to report that “In the 1990s, over a thousand British businesses invested in the National Lottery Contingency Scheme. If your staff won the jackpot, insurance payouts would help to cover recruitment, retraining, revenue losses, and temporary labor.”

Ben also points out that the employer could potentially self-insure by simply joining the employee pool and being one of the winner recipients (of course that assumes the employees even let the boss know what they're up to: "hey Boss, we're all joining together to win the lottery and quit this blankety-blank, friggin' workplace!").

…And if that’s not weird enough for you, shortly thereafter comes a section on “Alien-Abduction Insurance” :)  [...where Ben reports that a British company that sold 37,000 such plans hasn’t made a single payout yet (go figure!), and one of the managers involved says, “I’ve never been afraid of parting the feeble-minded from their cash”... so much for British understatement.]
Yeah, insurance is an interesting, creative business (selling you something you hope to never have to use).

Anyway, Ben’s book is a chuckle-a-minute, so if you want to insure against boredom, get it!
[The sections on probability and statistics constitute close to half the book and are especially fantastic, but the entire volume is a joy ride!]



Friday, October 5, 2018

Chi-i-i-i-i-i-ll Friday *




[*  "Chill Friday" is Math-Frolic's meditative musical diversion, heading into each weekend]